America's Most Critical Journal (since 1999)



A Brief History of Saint Nicholas

Illustration by Fred Schellart

One thing is clear: Christmas traditions differ in every country in which they are celebrated.

The pre-Christian Germanic peoples centered their winter celebration, Yule (which is still mentioned in the same breath as Christmas) around the god of Odin. Odin was a white-bearded gift-giver from the north, who rode a grey horse and often delivered runes as presents (much like the chocolate letters that Sinterklaas brings). Odin had black ravens, Huginn and Muninn, who gathered information for Odin, serving a function similar Sinterklaas’ Zwarte Piet. Odin is father of the Norse thunder god, Thor; later on Santa Claus will have reindeer named Donner (thunder) and Blitzen (lightning).

Meanwhile back in Christendom, Saint Nicholas (270 – 343), bishop of Myra, was an actual historical personage, who became known as the patron saint of children. Because his remains were interred in the then-Spanish city of Bari, it became tradition that he came from Spain, and was assisted by his Moorish pageboy, Zwarte Piet. In the middle ages, students began to celebrate Saint Nicholas festivals in schools and later in the towns. During the Dutch Golden Age, the Calvinist regents banned such celebrations, just as the Puritans in England also banned Christmas on the grounds that it was unbiblical, even pagan. 

Dutch settlers brought the Sinterklaas tradition with them to New York in the seventeenth century, where it slowly mixed with the British tradition of “Father Christmas.” In the U.S., the American Santa Claus evolved from the Dutch Sinterklaas, itself a contraction of Sint Nicolaas (others say it came from the German, Sankt Niklaus). Washington Irving (best known the author of “Rip van Winkel”) Americanized Sinterklaas into "Santa Claus" in his History of New York (1809), a lampoon of Dutch culture in New York.  In Irving’s work, Santa Claus departs from the bishop Saint Nicholas; he is depicted as a fat Dutch sailor in a green winter coat and smoking a pipe. In a dream sequence he drives a flying wagon.

In the landmark poem “A Visit from St. Nicholas" (1822) (“’Twas the Night Before Christmas” is the famous first line) Saint Nicholas leads a reindeer-led flying sled, and the children hang their stockings by the chimney. He is still called Saint Nicholas (not Santa Claus), but many other elements of the modern American Santa Claus are present. The “jolly old elf” has lost all traces of the Bishop Saint Nicholas.

Some 19th century Americans, in an attempt to Christianize the arguably pagan Santa Claus, also called Santa “Kris Kringle” (German for Christ child). To this day Christmas celebrations in the U.S. include both the purely religious celebrations of the birth of Christ as well as the less Christian Santa Claus stories.

Political cartoonist Thomas Nast in Harper’s Weekly (1863) drew Santa Claus dressed in a fur coat and smoking a clay pipe. Nast’s Santa Claus was decidedly pro-Union in the American Civil War (1861-65), so was used for political purposes.

Some of the final touches on the American image of Santa Claus were created by the Coca-Cola company, which in 1931 created a series of advertisements in which Santa either gives Coke as a present, or it is left for him as a present (a more sugary treat than the carrot left Sinterklaas’ horse).

After World War II, the American images of Santa Claus were exported around the world (along with Coca-Cola and other icons of American culture). Saint Nicholas still retains his traditional bishop’s appearance in Continental Europe.

Finally, here is an overview of differences between the Dutch Sinterklaas and the American Santa Claus.

Sinterklaas vs Santa Claus – Overview of Differences



Santa Claus

Recognized in …

Netherlands, Belgium, Germany, Austria

United States; known the world over

Year-round Residence

Lives in Spain

Lives at the North Pole

Marital Status / Family

Bachelor/Celibate Bishop

Married to Mrs. Claus (No kids)

Date for giving presents

Gives gifts on 5 December

Gives gifts on 25 December (or night before)


Is helped by (Black) Petes

Is helped by elves


Rides a white horse (Amerigo) and on a steamboat

Rides a sleigh pulled by flying reindeer (Dasher, Dancer, etc., and later Rudolph)

Location of gifts

Puts gifts in shoes

Puts gifts in stockings or under the Christmas tree

Food children leave

Carrot for the horse

Cookies and Milk for Santa. Optional carrot for the reindeer.

Later, a Coca-Cola.


6 December is his birthday.

25 December  (Jesus’ birthday in popular tradition)


Bishop’s garb (with cape)

Red suit, white-fringe, black belt


Wears a bishop’s mitre

Wears a red and white winter cap with a white pom-pom on the end.


Shepherd’s crosier

Big sack of toys


Punishments for naughty range from light (no candy) to severe (kidnapping to Spain for flogging by Black Peters)

Leaves a lump of coal as gift;

No corporal punishment

Is a Writer?

Writes charming poems that point out the foibles of the recipient

Not much of a writer

Intelligence Network

Relies on the Petes to gather information

Essentially omniscient (“He sees you when you’re sleeping; he knows when you’re awake.”)

Experiences “Senior Moments”?

Sometimes charmingly senile, relying on the Petes to remind him of things

Sharp as a tack.

Awareness of each other

Acknowledges that Santa exists.

Never acknowledges the existence of Sinterklaas



The True Story Of Santa Claus
America and the Creation of Santa Claus: A Guide
Saint Nicholas and the Origin of Santa Claus


Dan Geddes
19 December 2014